File-integrity checklist when a contract or exhibit may have been altered

Flat illustration of an edited hire agreement beside the original, a risk report and a warning sign

Short answer: if a contract or exhibit may have been altered, work on a copy, fingerprint the exact file you hold, compare it with any earlier fingerprint or signed original, gather how it reached you, and record every step. A matching fingerprint shows two files are identical. A mismatch shows they differ. Neither shows who made a change or why. TimeBinder does not detect AI or forgery.

Last checked 12 November 2026. General information, not legal advice.

Table of Contents

Before you do anything else

  1. Stop editing the file. Do not open and re-save the original. Opening and saving can change a file’s contents and its properties.
  2. Make a working copy. Keep the original untouched and do the checks on the copy.
  3. Write down the provenance now. Who sent it, when, by what channel, under what name, and what was said about it.

The file-integrity checklist

  1. Identify the exact file. Record the file name, format, size and its SHA-256 fingerprint. The free SHA-256 hash checker calculates it in your browser; the file does not leave your device.
  2. Look for an earlier fingerprint. Did anyone fingerprint or timestamp the signed or sent version at the time? If a fingerprint exists and matches, the file is identical to the one that was fingerprinted. If it does not match, the file differs. It does not tell you what differs.
  3. Collect other copies. Ask for the version in each party’s system, the native or editable version, and the email or portal copy. Fingerprint each and compare.
  4. Check the signing record. If the document was signed electronically, obtain the platform’s completion or audit record and the finished PDF it issued. See the section below on what that record covers.
  5. Compare content, not just fingerprints. If two versions differ, a document comparison tool can show where. Note that a comparison may be confused by re-exported or scanned pages.
  6. Check properties and metadata with caution. Dates, authors and edit history in a file are clues, not proof, because they can be changed or be wrong for innocent reasons.
  7. Preserve the chain of custody. Log who handled the file, when, and what was done. Our chain-of-custody log for digital exhibits has a template.
  8. Escalate where the stakes are high. A disputed document in a live matter may need a forensic examiner. See forensic examination vs an independent timestamp.
  9. Date what you now hold. A TimeBind for the file as you received it records that this exact file existed no later than the recorded time. It helps protect your own position from later arguments that you changed it.

What an e-signature record does and does not show

E-signature platforms keep a record of who was sent a document, who signed and when the process finished. E-signature platforms such as BoldSign, DocuSign and Adobe Acrobat Sign each produce a completion or audit record of this kind. That record starts with the signing request. It does not date drafts you never put into the envelope, and it does not show that a copy circulated by email afterwards is unchanged. We have not tested these services against each other, and others exist. See DocuSign certificate of completion vs a timestamp and timestamp vs electronic signature.

The practical step is to fingerprint the finished, signed PDF at once and keep that fingerprint with the completion record. Later copies can then be checked against it. TimeBinder does not replace a signature or a signing platform.

How courts approach authenticity

The rule is general, and the details depend on the court. Under U.S. Federal Rule of Evidence 901(a), the proponent of an item must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that it is what they claim it is. Rule 902(14) allows data copied from a device or file to be self-authenticated by a certification of a qualified person that it was authenticated by a process of digital identification, and the Committee Note explains that this is commonly done by hash value. That is about copies matching an original. The opponent can still challenge authenticity and other grounds such as hearsay.

In England and Wales, Practice Direction 32 says the parties should, where possible, agree that documents in a trial bundle are authentic, and that documents in agreed bundles are admissible as evidence of their contents unless a party gives written notice of objection. If you suspect alteration, say so early and in writing. A hash comparison is a useful, objective step. It is not a finding of forgery.

For a wider view of synthetic and altered evidence, see deepfake evidence and the rules and the lawyers’ guide to AI forgeries and backdating.

If the fingerprints do not match

  • Do not accuse anyone yet. Innocent causes include a re-save, a different export, a scan, an auto-update of a date field, or email software.
  • Record both fingerprints and where each file came from.
  • Ask each party for an explanation and their own copy.
  • Take advice about preservation duties and next steps. A qualified lawyer and, where needed, a forensic examiner should lead from here.

Prevention is simpler: fingerprint the signed version when it is signed. See how to prove a contract wasn’t edited after signing and, for law-firm workflows, legal timestamping.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can a hash show who altered a contract?

    No. A hash comparison shows whether two files are identical. It does not show who changed a file, when, or why.

  2. If the fingerprints match, is the contract genuine?

    A match shows the file is identical to the one that was fingerprinted. It does not show that the earlier file was genuine, signed by the right person or accurate.

  3. What if there is no earlier fingerprint?

    Then you cannot compare against one. Use the other steps: other copies, the signing platform record, the transmittal and chain of custody, and a specialist where needed. Fingerprint the file now so that future copies can be checked.

  4. Does TimeBinder detect forged or AI-altered documents?

    No. TimeBinder does not detect AI or forgery. A TimeBind is a dated, checkable record that an exact file existed no later than a recorded time and still matches.

  5. Do I need a forensic expert?

    Not for every query. If a document is central to a contested matter and you suspect alteration, get professional advice early on whether to instruct one.

Sources checked

Fingerprint the signed version when it is signed

Your first Pooled TimeBind is free, with no credit card required. After that, TimeBinds start from US$5, and an ASAP TimeBind is US$15. Click here to start, or see plans and pricing.